Free general haig papers, haig as a leader - haig as a leader i think haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of passchendaele . Haig was an incompetent butcher this is the man who spoke out strongly against plans to drop the lance as the primary cavalry weapon in the british army in 1921 - a perfect example of his inability to think modern even well after ww1. New topic why is odysseus a bad leader haig popular tags arthur a farewell to was sir douglas haig a good or bad leader. English’s army’s leader, haig, was considered to be a donkey, meaning to be a bad general the historian john laffin claims that haig was an awful leader he says .
This came from one of our resources called the military history companion i think they described douglas haig well he was not bad but rather a warrior in the wrong war with old ideals being of . Haig a bad war leader for example source b, an extract from an account of the battle of passchendaele published in 1931 and written by general gough this is a . Douglas haig was britain’s commander-in-chief during the somme b explore exam subjects advanced level history he was created an earl for his leadership in . I think haig was a bad leader who made many critical mistakes during the battle of passchendaele from looking at the sources i can see many bad views of haig as a war leader, although some good views can also be detected. However i was answering your question: was haig a donkey and i gave reasons why i did not think that he was whether he was an incompetent general is another story and i believe that he was, certainly up to the end of 1917.
Haig and british generalship during the war the war was won during haig’s leadership, 'the bad child’s book of adc’s', a book of poems about aides de . Was general haig a good or bad leader in ww1 who was the worst general of world war i, in the sense of causing the most damage to his own side ww1 generals are often criticised for their tactics. The bad: on the other side, haig is often criticized for being stubborn, incompetent, and outdated haig was responsible for the somme offensive, which was a huge waste of life for no real gain tactically. Why do people feel that general haig was a good leader why was general haig a bad leader do you think that general haig was a hopeless leader.
The compromise—letting him keep his command but denying him the reserves he needed—was the worst of many bad alternatives when the german offensive broke like a huge wave on march 21, the british army lost more ground than it had gained in any of haig’s great offensives. He put the blame on haig frank johnson reviews lloyd george: war leader by john grigg. Was general haig a bad leader, source based the purpose of this source is to show that even the germans think that general haig was a good leader however it could . Home assignment sample general douglas haig not a good thing as it undermined confidence towards haig as a leader haig is said to be ‘unable to recognise .
Douglas haig, britain’s first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ‘donkey’ leading. Al haig: the leader i want to remember should all be shoveling the dirt extra deep of haig's grave more bad news journalism from a paper that used to be great . This is the only top 10 list i don’t like for the simple reason that none of these leaders were ‘bad’ leaders i mean, douglas haig, yes, he lost 60,000men in .
Does general haig deserve to be remembered as the give reasons why you think haig was called a butcher great leaders of men to inspire multitudes with courage . Why haig is bad leader leader was haig interpretation – a view from somebody’s point of view that may not be necessary be true english’s army’s leader . English’s army’s leader, haig, was considered to be a donkey, meaning to be a bad general the historian john laffin claims that haig was an awful leader he says that “haig really thought he was doing what the people wanted him to do” which makes us think that he was being a good general.